BimpBlog

Bill of Materials vs Routing: What Is the Difference and When You Need Both

Bill of materials vs routing: what each document describes, a comparison table, one pedestal unit in both documents and how Bimp joins them in a specification.

DO
Dmytro ObukhovCo-Founder & CEO
Table of contents
In short
  • A bill of materials (BOM) answers "what is the product made of and how much material goes into it", and a routing (technological card) answers "how and in what order is it made". The first serves purchasing and reserves, the second serves the shop and labor pay.
  • In the example, a three-drawer pedestal unit has five materials worth €95.80 in the BOM and four operations worth €23.50 and 1.9 hours in the routing. Without the routing the cost looks like €95.80 instead of €119.30, an understatement of 19.7%.
  • Both documents are needed when a product passes several stages, workers are paid piece rate or part of the work goes to contractors. For assembling kits without operations, the BOM is enough.
  • In Bimp, materials and stages with operations live in one Specification document: materials on one tab, stages and operations on another. Processing modes and acceptance criteria do not exist there as separate fields.

A bill of materials answers the question “what is the product made of and how much material is in it”, and a routing (technological card) answers “how and in what order is it made”. The first serves purchasing, the reserve and the calculation of material cost, the second serves the shop, time norming and labor pay. In Bimp both parts are collected in one Specification document.

A shop technologist brings the director a calculation: a pedestal unit costs €95.80. The director sets the price from that figure, and a month later it turns out that every unit is unprofitable against the plan. The reason is that the calculation held only materials. The work of cutting, edge banding, assembly and packing did not get into it. The rest of the article looks at how the two documents differ, using one pedestal unit. The company is hypothetical.

What are a bill of materials and a routing?

A bill of materials (BOM) is a list of the materials and parts of one product with quantity, unit of measure and loss percentage. It is covered in detail in the article What is a bill of materials (BOM).

A routing is a document that describes how to get the product from these materials: which jobs to perform, in what order, with what time norms, who performs them and by what criterion the result is accepted further. So a routing is a document about the process, and a bill of materials is a document about the composition.

What is the difference between a bill of materials and a routing?

The difference is easy to see by asking four questions of each document: what is in it, who needs it, what is calculated from it and what happens if it is missing.

CriterionBill of materialsRouting
Main questionwhat from and how muchhow, in what order, in how much time
Main contentmaterials, parts, quantities, lossesstages, operations, time norms, performers, acceptance criteria
Who uses itbuyer, storekeeper, economisttechnologist, foreman, production head
What is calculatedmaterial requirement, material costlabor input, cost of work, deadlines
What happens without itinaccurate purchasing and reserveno time norms, pay by guesswork, cost understated
In Bimp“Materials and components” tab“Stages and operations” tab

This table describes the classic split. In a system that keeps the records, the two parts are linked: a material is tied to the stage where it is consumed, and the cost of operations flows into the same cost price. That is why separate sheets for the technologist and for the economist drift apart over time, while one document keeps them together.

What does one pedestal unit look like in the bill of materials and in the routing?

A hypothetical manufacturer makes a three-drawer pedestal unit. Below is its bill of materials: what goes into one product and what it costs.

MaterialNorm per productPrice, EURAmount, EUR
Chipboard 16 mm, m²1.83868.40
PVC edging, m90.605.40
Drawer slides, pair34.5013.50
Hardware, set15.505.50
Packaging set13.003.00
Total materials95.80

Check: 68.40 + 5.40 + 13.50 + 5.50 + 3.00 = €95.80 per product. This is what the buyer needs: for a batch of 40 units it is 95.8 × 40 = €3,832, and the board needed is 1.8 × 40 = 72 m².

The routing of the same unit describes the work.

StageOperationNorm, hCost, EURCriterion to pass on
CuttingBoard cutting0.56.00part dimensions match the drawing
Edge bandingBanding of parts0.45.00edging fits tightly, no peeling
AssemblyAssembly of carcass and drawers0.810.00drawers run without sticking
PackingPacking0.22.50set is complete, unit is labeled
Total1.923.50

Check: 0.5 + 0.4 + 0.8 + 0.2 = 1.9 hours, 6 + 5 + 10 + 2.5 = €23.50 per product. For a batch of 40 units that is 1.9 × 40 = 76 hours and 23.5 × 40 = €940.

The full planned cost of a unit: 95.8 + 23.5 = €119.30. The bill of materials alone gives €95.80, so the full cost is understated by €23.50, or by 23.5 / 119.3 = 19.7%. At a dealer price of €240, the gross profit seems to be 240 - 95.8 = €144.20 from the bill of materials, and by the two documents it is only 240 - 119.3 = €120.70. The difference is €23.50 on every unit, and €940 on a batch of 40.

The acceptance criteria in the last column exist only in a paper routing. In a Bimp specification, the fields filled in for operations are quantity, execution time, priority, dependency on the previous operation, performer, contract and cost. There are no fields for processing modes or acceptance criteria, so the technologist keeps such requirements in a separate document.

When are both documents needed, and when is the bill of materials enough?

Both are needed when a product passes several stages and money or deadlines depend on them. The bill of materials is enough when the work comes down to kitting.

Both are needed if:

  1. The product passes several stages, and each needs its own materials, for example cutting and assembly.
  2. Workers are paid piece rate: the rate comes from the operation. For piece-rate pay the operation is set with an accrual type, and Bimp pulls the rate and the list of available workers.
  3. Contractors perform some operations: the specification names a contract for them, and settlement for the work is made when the production is closed.
  4. You need to see at which stage a product is and where the delay is: without stages in the specification, a production task has nothing to build steps from.
  5. You calculate the cost of work in progress: cost accumulates by stage.

The bill of materials is enough if the product is assembled from ready components without separate operations and the cost of work is included in the price of the set. A typical example is a gift set of three goods or a “laptop and bag” kit.

What do you do when the technology has changed?

Materials get more expensive, operations disappear or are added, and old orders still have to be calculated on the old technology. For this a specification has a “Version” field and a kind: “Main” by default or “Non-main”. A new version is created next to the old one, and the production order pulls the specification you chose on the “Products” tab.

An example: the pedestal unit started to be assembled on new drawer slides that cost €0.50 more per pair. Three pairs give 3 × 0.5 = €1.50 per product, and for a batch of 40 that is 1.5 × 40 = €60. The material cost of the new version is 95.8 + 1.5 = €97.30, and the full cost is 97.3 + 23.5 = €120.80. Old orders stay on version 1 at €119.30, new ones go on version 2.

How is this set up in Bimp?

In Bimp the specification is also the technological card of the product: it is one document in “Production → Specifications”. First you fill in the left panel: the product, the quantity, the version, the group, the currency, the type and the kind of specification. Then you turn on the “Use stages and operations” switch, and the tabs appear on the right.

On the “Stages and operations” tab you add stages in the order of manufacture and the operations in each one, with time norms and cost. On the “Materials and components” tab you tie materials to each stage with quantity and loss percentage. At the bottom you see the totals of materials and operations and the planned cost. A material without a stage or without a quantity does not enter the calculation, so it cannot be overlooked.

Next, the production order pulls the products, materials and operations from the specification, and “Assembly” writes off the materials and accrues piece rate. All fields are described in the help article Specifications, and for large catalogs there is import of specifications from Excel. For the page aimed at technologists, see the Bimp site.

What Bimp does and does not do

Bimp is a Ukrainian cloud ERP for manufacturers. In one specification it keeps materials, stages and operations, versions and the rules for replacing materials with analogues, calculates the planned cost by remaining value or by the last purchase price, and then uses this data in the production order, in “Assembly” and in production tasks. A specification can be printed from its card.

What is missing. Processing modes, the list of equipment and tools, drawings and acceptance criteria have no separate fields in a specification, and they are kept in their own documents. Bimp does not invent norms: they are taken from your specification, so a mistake in a time norm or a material quantity will reach the cost. The start and finish dates of production are set by a person.

The summary of the example: the pedestal unit’s bill of materials gave €95.80 of materials and a need of 72 m² of board for a batch of 40, the routing added €23.50 and 1.9 hours per product, and only together did they give the true cost of €119.30. Start with materials, then add operations for the products that are paid by piece rate or that involve contractors.

FAQ

What is a routing (technological card)?

A routing, or technological card, describes how to make a product: which operations to perform, in what order, with what time norms and by what criterion to accept the result. It answers "how", while the bill of materials answers "what from".

How does a bill of materials differ from a routing?

A bill of materials lists the materials and parts of a product with quantities and losses. A routing adds the sequence of operations, time norms, performers and requirements for the result. Both parts are needed to calculate the full cost.

Can you do without a routing?

Yes, if the product is assembled from ready components without separate operations and labor pay does not depend on stages. If the shop has several stages, piece-rate pay or contractors, the operations need to be described.

How are the bill of materials and the routing distinguished in Bimp?

They are one document. On the "Materials and components" tab you list the materials, and on the "Stages and operations" tab the sequence of work, time norms, performers and cost. The operations tab appears after you turn on the "Use stages and operations" switch.

Can specifications be imported from Excel?

Yes, in "Production → Specifications" the "Import" button loads a file by template. Bimp finds the product and the components by SKU, so they must be in the product catalog before the import.

We will show a specification with operations on your product

In a Bimp ERP demo, a specialist enters your product with materials, stages and operations with time norms, and shows the planned cost and how the data passes to the production order.

Book a demo
DODmytro ObukhovCo-Founder & CEO