Table of contents
- How does make to order differ from make to stock?
- Which scheme should you choose for which product?
- How does a desk shop work under both schemes?
- When should a batch for stock be started?
- How are both schemes run in Bimp?
- What do you do when a customer orders a product that does not exist yet?
- What Bimp does and does not do
- FAQ
- Make to order starts after the customer confirms, and make to stock produces ahead of time for expected demand. Most shops combine both: popular models for stock, custom products to order.
- In the example, a shop makes the "Office-120" desk for stock in batches of 50 and desks to customer dimensions to order. The warehouse holds on average €7,750 of finished goods, and custom orders give 8.3% of revenue and 11.8% of gross profit.
- In Bimp both schemes use the same documents. To order: customer order, production order, assembly. For stock: the production order is created by hand, and the customer later buys a finished product from the balance.
- Bimp does not start batches for stock automatically: a person sets the trigger level by looking at the "Available" column.
Make to order starts after the customer has confirmed the purchase, and make to stock produces a batch ahead of time and sells from the finished balance. Most shops work under both schemes at once, and in Bimp the documents are the same: only what triggers production changes.
Every Friday the foreman of a furniture shop decides whether to cut another 50 desks for stock. If he errs on the high side, board sits in finished products and ties up cash. If he errs on the low side, a dealer waits a week. The rest of the article compares the two schemes, shows a hypothetical shop with the arithmetic and gives a rule with a specific number for starting a batch for stock. The company is hypothetical.
How does make to order differ from make to stock?
The difference is the moment of the start and who carries the risk. In make to order the customer carries the demand risk: they wait, but pay for a product that already has a buyer. In make to stock the shop takes the risk: the product is made, and whether anyone buys it depends on sales.
| Indicator | Make to order | Make to stock |
|---|---|---|
| What starts production | a confirmed customer order | stock level or sales plan |
| Finished product in the warehouse | none until the end of the cycle | yes, shipped on the day of the order |
| Lead time for the customer | the whole production cycle | shipping time |
| Cash tied up | materials for the order during the cycle | cost of the finished goods balance |
| Risk of an unsold product | none | yes |
| Price | reflects individual requirements | by price list |
| Typical products | custom sizes, configurations, projects | popular models, components, consumables |
There is also a third option: assembly from semi-finished products. The shop keeps blanks in stock (cut parts, frames) and does the final assembly to order. The cycle gets shorter, and finished products do not pile up. How to handle such blanks is described in the article about semi-finished products and a multi-level bill of materials.
Which scheme should you choose for which product?
The scheme is chosen for each product separately, so one shop easily holds both. A product suits stock if it is bought regularly and in the same form: demand is stable, there are few variants, the customer does not want to wait. A product is made to order when the size, color or configuration depends on the customer, or when sales are irregular and a batch for stock would sit for a long time.
Four questions help with the choice:
- How many variants of the product you sell. Three models are easy to hold in stock, three hundred combinations almost impossible.
- Whether the customer tolerates waiting. A dealer who needs to restock a showcase will not wait five days.
- What share of the cost is material. Expensive raw material makes a warehouse of finished products costly.
- Whether demand can be predicted. If sales have been steady for the last months, stock is justified.
The decision for a product can be reviewed. A model that began to sell regularly moves from made-to-order to stock, and one that stopped selling moves back.
How does a desk shop work under both schemes?
A hypothetical shop makes office desks. The “Office-120” model sells every week, over the last four weeks: 22, 26, 24 and 28 units. Total 22 + 26 + 24 + 28 = 100 units, on average 25 units a week. This model is made for stock in batches of 50. Desks to customer dimensions, on average 6 a month, are made only after confirmation.
| Indicator | “Office-120” (for stock) | Desk to customer size (to order) |
|---|---|---|
| Sales per month, pcs | 100 | 6 |
| Price, EUR | 480 | 720 |
| Cost, EUR | 310 | 340 |
| Gross profit per desk, EUR | 170 | 380 |
| Lead time for the customer | shipped on the day of the order | 5 working days |
Revenue for the month: 100 × 480 = €48,000 plus 6 × 720 = €4,320, total €52,320. Gross profit: 100 × 170 = €17,000 plus 6 × 380 = €2,280, total €19,280, or about 37% of revenue.
Custom orders give 4,320 / 52,320 = 8.3% of revenue but 2,280 / 19,280 = 11.8% of gross profit. They are pricier, and there is no cost of idle cash behind them: materials are reserved for the order only for the length of the cycle, 6 × 340 = €2,040.
Stock costs more. A batch of 50 units has a cost of 50 × 310 = €15,500. If 25 units are sold a week, the balance swings from 50 to 0, on average 25 units, so 25 × 310 = €7,750 sits constantly in finished products. This is the price of instant shipping for a dealer.
When should a batch for stock be started?
A batch is started when the available balance covers only the production time plus a margin. The formula: start level = demand during the production period + safety stock. In the example a batch is made in a week, demand is 25 units and safety stock is 10 units, so the start level is 25 + 10 = 35 units.
Check: when the available balance falls to 35 units, the shop starts a batch. Over the week 25 units sell, leaving 35 - 25 = 10 units, so the safety stock is untouched. Then 50 units arrive, and the balance becomes 10 + 50 = 60 units. The balance will reach the next start level in (60 - 35) / 25 = 1 week.
The word “available” matters here. A balance of 40 units with a reserve of 15 units gives only 25 units available. In Bimp the available balance is visible in the Warehouse → Products and services list, in the columns “Stock in warehouses”, “Reserve” and “Available”. A reserve reduces “Available”, while the warehouse balance does not change, so the start level is compared with the available figure. More on reserving finished products is in the help article Reserving goods.
How are both schemes run in Bimp?
For make to order the scheme is this. A manager accepts a customer order, creates a production order from it, and materials by the specification are reserved for that customer. After production, “Assembly” is posted: materials are written off, the product is received into stock, then it is shipped. All steps are covered in the article about the production order and in the help article Production order.
For stock the scheme starts with a different document. The production order is created by hand through Production → Production orders → Create, without a customer order: it is a batch of 50 “Office-120” desks with start and finish dates. “Assembly” receives the batch into the warehouse. When a dealer orders a desk, the manager creates a customer order, and the product is reserved from the balance like any other item.
Both schemes show in the Production Progress report: for each production order it shows how much was ordered, produced, left to make and shipped. Batches for stock and customer orders stand side by side in it, so the shop head sees the whole workload in one list.
What do you do when a customer orders a product that does not exist yet?
Selling without a balance helps here. A customer asks for 40 “Office-120” desks and 25 are available. The manager creates a customer order for 40 units, leaves 25 in the “Reserve” column and sells the rest against the next batch. The customer pays, and after “Assembly” the manager ships the 15 units that were missing: 40 - 25 = 15.
If the product cannot be reserved at all, the “Reserve” column is set to 0. By default Bimp tries to reserve the whole quantity, and with a zero balance a conflict arises: the order is not posted, or a virtual negative appears in the reports. A zero reserve removes it, and the invoice and the buyer’s payment are handled as usual. A step-by-step guide for goods that are not in stock is in the help article Selling goods that are out of stock. The same technique works for products of your own production.
What Bimp does and does not do
Bimp is a Ukrainian cloud ERP for manufacturers. It keeps customer orders, production orders (from a customer order or by hand), the reserve of materials and finished products, “Assembly” with the write-off of materials and the receipt of the product, shipping and reports: stock with reserve, production progress, cost. The available balance is visible for each warehouse.
What the system does not do. It does not start batches for stock by itself: the start level, the batch size and the safety stock are set by you from your sales, and Bimp shows the balance and the reserve on which the decision is made. There is no demand forecast in it. The start and finish dates of production are set by a person. For calculating dates by capacity, see the Bimp site.
In the example the desk shop received three numbers for the decision: the warehouse holds €7,750 of finished products, custom orders give 11.8% of gross profit at 8.3% of revenue, and a batch for stock should be started at an available balance of 35 units. You will get your own numbers from the same data: sales for several weeks, the cost of the product and the available balance.
FAQ
What is make to order?
It is a scheme in which the shop starts making a product after the customer has confirmed the order. In English it is called make to order (MTO). There is no finished product in the warehouse, so the customer waits for the whole production cycle.
What is make to stock?
It is the production of a batch of finished products ahead of time for expected demand. The customer buys the product from the balance and receives it on the day of the order, and the shop carries the risk that part of the batch will sit unsold.
Can both schemes be combined in one system?
Yes. In Bimp a production order can be created from a customer order or by hand, without a customer. The first gives make to order, the second gives make to stock.
How do you sell a product that is not in the warehouse yet?
Create a customer order, set the "Reserve" column to 0 or to the quantity that is in stock, take a prepayment and ship the rest after production.
When should a new batch for stock be started?
When the available balance (stock minus reserve) falls to a level that covers demand during production plus a safety stock. In the example of the article it is 35 pcs: 25 pcs of demand over a week of production and 10 pcs of safety stock.
In a Bimp ERP demo, a specialist runs one product two ways: from a customer order and as a batch for stock, with the reserve, assembly and the balance of finished goods.
Book a demo