BimpBlog

Returning Defective Components to the Supplier: A Batch of Drivers With 8% Defects and a €2,100 Debt

Example of a fictional luminaire maker: returning defective components to the supplier, the debt after an advance and a refund in Bimp, step by step.

DO
Dmytro ObukhovCo-Founder & CEO
Table of contents
In short
  • Returning defective components to the supplier is recorded with a "Return to supplier" document created from the goods receipt. For a batch of 2,000 drivers at €2.50 (€5,000) with 8% defects that is 160 pieces worth €400.
  • The debt to the supplier drops automatically: 5,000 - 2,500 (advance) = €2,500 before the return and 2,500 - 400 = €2,100 after. There is no need to pay more than this amount.
  • The supplier refunds money only when the payment already exceeds the value of the goods accepted. Then a "Supplier refund" is recorded, or the sum is credited against the next delivery with a debt adjustment.

The company is fictional. Every action in Bimp is a real product feature. The figures in the example are invented, and the arithmetic can be checked on a calculator.

Returning defective components to the supplier answers one question: how much do we owe now. A fictional luminaire maker received 2,000 power drivers at €2.50, €5,000 in all. At incoming inspection 8% turned out defective, that is 160 pieces worth €400. An advance of €2,500 had already gone to the supplier. After the defects are returned in Bimp the debt is €2,100, and this figure is visible in the report with no spreadsheet counting.

Before, the purchasing manager kept the defective drivers “pending review” in a corner of the warehouse. Nobody knew how much was owed to the supplier: accounting had one figure, purchasing another.

Why do defective drivers lie “pending review” for months?

“Lumen Rhythm” (a fictional company) makes luminaires and has 40 employees. It buys power drivers from two suppliers and pays for part of a batch in advance. A luminaire is assembled from a driver, a housing and a lens, so a defect in one component stops assembly.

The batch arrived, incoming inspection sorted out the faulty drivers, and no documents appeared after that. The manager waited for the supplier’s reply, the storekeeper did not know whether to write off the defective drivers, and the accountant paid the invoice in full, because in the documents everything looked like a normal receipt.

The figures of the batch are these.

IndicatorPiecesAmount, €
Arrived per the delivery note (2,000 × 2.50)2,0005,000
Defects 8% (2,000 × 0.08 = 160)160400
Usable drivers1,8404,600
Advance paid2,500

Check: 1,840 × 2.50 = 4,600, and 4,600 + 400 = 5,000. Defects take 8% of the batch value, and without a document that money stays in the debt.

How do you record the return of defective components to the supplier in Bimp?

Each step is described in the help, with a link next to it. Incoming defects differ from defects in production: the cause lies with the supplier, so the dispute is handled with him. How to count scrap inside the workshop is covered in the material Scrap Accounting in Manufacturing.

Step 1. Receipt and advance. The batch is recorded with a “Goods receipt” document (Goods receipt): supplier, contract, warehouse, 2,000 drivers at €2.50. On posting a debt of €5,000 arises. The advance of €2,500 is recorded as a supplier payment and allocated to the order. Then settlements show it: half is paid, the other half is owed.

Step 2. Return of goods. When inspection has sorted out 160 drivers, open the receipt and click “Create based on”, the item “Return to supplier”. The items are pulled in automatically. In the row change the quantity from 2,000 to 160 (Return to supplier). After saving, the goods are written off the warehouse and the debt to the supplier drops by the amount of the return.

Step 3. Money or an offset. Here the scenario branches depending on how much has already been paid. In our example €2,500 is paid and goods worth €4,600 have been accepted. We still owe the supplier €2,100, so nothing is to be refunded: we pay less. If the batch had been paid in full, he would owe us €400. Then a Supplier refund is created from the return, stating which debt it closes. Or the parties agree on an offset and record a debt adjustment.

Step 4. Replacement. Luminaire assembly does not wait. If an analogue is added in the driver’s card, for example a model from the second supplier, the manager suggests a replacement with the current stock and price (Product analogues). Defects stop holding up assembly.

Step 5. Reports. The “Settlements with suppliers” report shows the debt per contract (report). The “Receipts by Supplier” analysis gives ordered, received and returned (report).

Challenge

A batch of 2,000 drivers worth €5,000 arrived with 8% defects. The advance of €2,500 is paid, the defective drivers lie “pending review”, and nobody knows how much is owed to the supplier.

Solution with Bimp

The return is recorded with a document created from the receipt. It writes 160 drivers off the warehouse and reduces the debt. Money has its own document, a supplier refund, or a debt adjustment, and the reports show settlements and the share of defects by supplier.

Result in numbers

Defects 160 × 2.50 = €400. Debt before the return 5,000 - 2,500 = €2,500, after the return 2,500 - 400 = €2,100. The decision whether to take money back or offset is made from the figure in the report.

How much do we owe the supplier after the return?

The debt is calculated from the documents in this order.

EventDebt to the supplier, €
Receipt of 2,000 drivers5,000
Advance5,000 - 2,500 = 2,500
Return of 160 defective drivers2,500 - 400 = 2,100

The accountant pays the remaining €2,100 for the usable drivers. No money for the defects is needed from the supplier: we had not paid it yet, the advance covered only part of the batch, and the return reduced the balance.

The picture changes when payment runs ahead of inspection. Suppose the batch was paid in full, €5,000. After the return the supplier owes us €400. There are two ways. The first: ask for the money, record a “Supplier refund” from the return and see the receipt on the account. The second: credit the €400 against the next delivery. For the next batch worth €2,600 we would pay 2,600 - 400 = €2,200, and in settlements a debt adjustment shows this.

The choice depends on the situation. If the next delivery is already planned, the offset saves a movement of money. If the supplier’s reliability is in doubt, it is safer to take the money back at once.

How do you spot a supplier who ships defects systematically?

Defects happen to everyone once. When they repeat, the buyer needs statistics. The “Receipts by Supplier” analysis builds them from the documents: for each supplier it shows the quantity received and returned for the period.

For our example, two suppliers over a quarter look like this.

SupplierReceived, pcsReturned, pcsReturn share
Supplier 12,0001608%
Supplier 21,500151%

Check: 160 / 2,000 = 0.08, and 15 / 1,500 = 0.01. The difference is eightfold. The buyer goes to the first supplier with a figure: 8% in a quarter against 2% allowed by the contract. The claim carries weight because it stands on documents. He can ask for a discount on the next delivery or move part of the order to the second supplier, whose price is €2.60 instead of €2.50 and whose defects are 1%.

A short calculation helps to compare suppliers by full cost. A driver at €2.50 with 8% defects costs 2.50 / 0.92 = €2.72 per usable piece. A driver at €2.60 with 1% defects costs 2.60 / 0.99 = €2.63. The offer that is dearer on paper turns out cheaper by about €0.09 a piece. On 1,840 usable drivers that is about €168 of difference. How to count purchasing in more depth is described in the material Safety Stock and Reorder Point.

What do you do with the defective drivers before the supplier arrives?

While the supplier decides how to collect the batch, the 160 drivers physically lie in the warehouse. The return document in Bimp is recorded on the day of rejection, with no wait for the shipment. The warehouse shows the correct stock: 1,840 usable drivers that can go into luminaires. The production planner does not count on those 160 pieces, and the buyer sees the shortage at once.

The shortage is easy to count. If 2,000 drivers are needed for the month and 1,840 are usable, 160 pieces are missing. The replacement is ordered from the second supplier on the day of rejection. At €2.60 that is 160 × 2.60 = €416. The difference from the first supplier’s price (€400) is €16, and this sum is also part of the cost of the defects. The owner sees the full price of the problem: the money for the defective drivers plus the surcharge for an urgent replacement.

What does this give?

The buyer sees the debt per contract in one report and does not have to reconcile it with the accountant. The storekeeper knows what to do with defective drivers: they are handed over with a return document and disappear from the warehouse. The accountant does not pay the invoice in full when part of the batch has gone back.

The owner gets a solid argument in talks with the supplier: the share of defects for the quarter comes from documents. Bimp is a Ukrainian cloud ERP for manufacturers, and receipts, returns, payments and supplier reports live in one system. How this looks for luminaire production in general is described on the page Bimp for manufacturers.

Scenario limits

The scenario describes a return when defects were found after receipt. Bimp does not check the supplier contract terms on penalties and warranty periods: the manager keeps them in mind. The decision whether to take money or an offset is made by people, and the system shows how much it comes to. Check the button names in the interface against your version. All amounts in the example are invented.

FAQ

Does the "Return to supplier" document return the money?

No. It writes the goods off the warehouse and reduces the debt to the supplier. The receipt of money is recorded with a separate "Supplier refund" document, created from the return.

How do you return only part of a batch to the supplier?

Create the return from the receipt and change the quantity in the row to the actual defective amount, for example 160 drivers out of 2,000. The rest of the batch stays in the warehouse and in the debt.

What if the supplier offers to credit an overpayment against the next delivery?

Record a debt adjustment. The overpayment becomes an offset in settlements with this supplier, and the "Settlements with suppliers" report shows it next to the other documents.

Where can you see how many defects different suppliers brought?

In the "Receipts by Supplier" analysis. For each supplier it shows how much was ordered, received and returned.

See your supplier in the documents

In a Bimp ERP demo a specialist records the return of a defective batch of your components with you and shows how the debt to the supplier changes.

Book a demo
DODmytro ObukhovCo-Founder & CEO