Table of contents
- Subcontractor services accounting in metalworking starts in the specification: galvanizing and heat treatment sit there as separate stages with a performer and a contract. For a batch of 500 axles the planned cost is €26 a piece, or €13,000.
- The subcontractor charged €1.40 for galvanizing instead of €1.20 and €150 separately for delivery. The actual cost is €13,250, or €26.50 a piece. The €250 difference shows on the day the service is received, long before the quarterly reconciliation.
- Debt to the subcontractor arises with the service receipt and is closed by a payment against a specific supplier order. Its status shows in the "Supplier Settlements" report.
The company is fictional. Every action in Bimp is a real product feature. The figures in the example are invented, and the manufacturer matches no real enterprise.
Subcontractor services accounting in metalworking needs three things: the subcontractor’s operation in the product routing, a separate debt to them and the actual figure in the batch cost. For a fictional batch of 500 axles Ø40 the planned calculation gives €26 a piece, or €13,000. After the galvanizing certificate and delivery the actual cost is €13,250, which is €26.50 a piece.
The plant owner used to learn about the €250 difference a quarter later. The subcontractor’s invoice arrived a month on, the batch cost was recorded as an estimate, and debts were counted in a notebook. Twice in a quarter the wrong amount was paid.
Why is the cost of an axle batch known only a quarter later?
Metal-Profile (a fictional company) machines parts for agricultural equipment makers and has 70 employees. Turning and milling are done in the shop, while heat treatment and galvanizing go to two subcontractors.
An axle Ø40 is turned in the shop, then heat-treated and galvanized by the subcontractors. The planned calculation per piece is as follows.
| Component | Who performs it | Plan per piece, € | Plan per batch of 500, € |
|---|---|---|---|
| Metal (blank) | warehouse | 14.00 | 7,000 |
| Turning | own employees | 9.00 | 4,500 |
| Heat treatment | subcontractor 1 | 1.80 | 900 |
| Galvanizing | subcontractor 2 | 1.20 | 600 |
| Total | 26.00 | 13,000 |
Check: 14 + 9 + 1.8 + 1.2 = 26, and 26 × 500 = 13,000. The subcontractors take €3 of the €26, which is 11.5% of the plan. When their invoices arrive late, this share remains an estimate, while the in-house part is already closed with actuals.
How do you account for subcontractor services in Bimp in six steps?
Each step is described in the help center, with the link next to it.
Step 1. Subcontractors, contracts, services. In the counterparty directory you create two suppliers and a supplier contract for each: currency and payment deferral. A new supplier is added by the instruction Adding a supplier. The products catalog gets the services “Heat treatment” and “Galvanizing” with the “Service” type. The service card carries an expense item from the “Cost price” group, otherwise the amount goes to period expenses and does not reach the batch (Purchasing services).
Step 2. The axle specification. In the specification you create stages. “Turning” has an operation at €9 for own employees, while “Heat treatment” and “Galvanizing” have a counterparty with a contract as the performer and costs of €1.80 and €1.20. The planned cost total sits at the bottom of the tab: €26 a piece.
Step 3. Production order. The manager creates a production order for 500 axles. For an assembly of several parts, “Create production orders” is turned on, and subordinate orders for semi-finished goods are generated automatically. The operation columns show that galvanizing will be done by an outside subcontractor.
Step 4. Assembly. When the metal has been machined, you post the assembly. It writes off the metal, posts the axles to stock, accrues piecework pay to the turners and creates a supplier order for the subcontractors. There is no need to write this order out by hand.
Step 5. Service receipt and payment. When the subcontractor has returned the axles and sent the certificate, you create a goods receipt from the supplier order. The amount comes from the certificate: €1.40 × 500 = €700 instead of the planned €600. Posting creates a debt to the subcontractor. The payment is created from the same supplier order (Supplier payment), and the debt is closed against the right document.
The subcontractor billed delivery separately at €150. It is added to the batch with the “Additional costs” document and the “Production” operation (Additional costs). The debt to the carrier appears together with this document.
Step 6. Reports. The “Supplier Settlements” report shows, for each subcontractor, how many services were received, how much was paid and what remains (report). The “Cost of Produced Goods” report gives the actual cost per batch, which you compare with the specification plan (report).
The subcontractor’s invoice arrives a month later, so the cost of a batch of 500 axles is fixed as an estimate. Debt to subcontractors is kept in a notebook, and twice in a quarter the wrong amount was paid.
Galvanizing and heat treatment sit in the specification as subcontractor operations with a contract. The assembly creates the supplier order, the service receipt records the debt, and the reports show the debt and the batch cost.
Plan 14 + 9 + 1.8 + 1.2 = €26 a piece, €13,000 a batch. Actual: galvanizing €1.40 instead of €1.20, delivery €150. Total €13,250, or €26.50 a piece. The €250 deviation (1.9%) shows on the day the service is received.
How much does the deviation cost and where did it come from?
The deviation splits into two parts: €100 for the higher galvanizing price (€0.20 × 500) and €150 for delivery that was not in the plan. Together €250. Check: 13,000 + 250 = 13,250, and 13,250 / 500 = €26.50 a piece. The deviation is 250 / 13,000 = 1.9% of the plan.
For a batch with a sale price of €32 a piece, which is €16,000 of revenue, the result is this.
| Indicator | Plan | Actual |
|---|---|---|
| Batch cost, € | 13,000 | 13,250 |
| Profit, € | 3,000 | 2,750 |
| Profitability | 18.8% | 17.2% |
Profitability 3,000 / 16,000 = 18.75%, and 2,750 / 16,000 = 17.19%. A loss of 1.6 percentage points looks small, but it came from two causes on a single batch. If the subcontractor raises the galvanizing price by another 10 cents and delivery becomes regular, the margin on the axle falls noticeably. The owner sees this on every batch and negotiates with the subcontractor while the order is still in work.
When a certificate arrives backdated, the cost in sales already made is updated by reposting. How this works and why reports stay intact is covered in Cost Recalculation When an Invoice Arrives Late.
How do you avoid paying a subcontractor the wrong amount?
Errors in the amount appeared because the debt lay in a notebook, apart from the documents. In Bimp the debt equals the difference between what the subcontractor performed and what we paid. An example for the galvanizing of the batch.
| Indicator in the report for subcontractor 2 | Amount, € |
|---|---|
| Opening balance | 0 |
| Purchases (per certificate: 1.40 × 500) | 700 |
| Paid (advance) | 300 |
| Closing balance | 400 |
A positive closing balance means a debt to the subcontractor, a negative one means an advance for a service not yet rendered. The accountant does not have to remember what has already been paid: they open the contract in the report and see €400. If the payment was created from the supplier order for which the receipt was posted, the debt is closed against the right document. The accountant’s actions that used to cause errors are now checked by the report.
The second subcontractor, who does the heat treatment, issued a certificate for 1.80 × 500 = €900, and the plant paid it in full. The closing balance for them is €0. The total debt for the batch is €400 to the galvanizer and €150 to the carrier, €550 together. The accountant sees this amount in the report without notebook arithmetic and decides which payment to plan for the week.
With more than two subcontractors, the report is grouped by supplier and contract. It then shows who still has a balance after payments and to whom the plant owes nothing but holds an advance. The buyer talks to the subcontractor with figures in hand: “you have a certificate for 700, we have paid 300”. Paying the wrong amount gets harder, because every payment is tied to a supplier order and the balance shows in the same report. If a subcontractor sends a reminder for a larger sum, the accountant checks it against the receipts under the contract and finds the discrepancy within a minute.
What does this give the company?
The plant owner gets the actual cost of a batch right after the service is received. Decisions on price, on changing the subcontractor or on demanding a discount are made on figures that already exist, without waiting for the end-of-quarter reconciliation.
The accountant closes debts by documents. The process engineer sees that the subcontractor’s operation is part of the process: its rate sits in the specification next to the turning rate. The buyer tracks deviations by subcontractor and by delivery. Bimp is a cloud ERP for manufacturers, built in Ukraine, and the specification, supplier order, debt and cost work in one system, with no exports between programs.
Scenario limits
The scenario describes a batch where subcontractors perform operations on the plant’s own metal, and their services are bought under a contract. Accounting for customer-supplied material, where the metal belongs to the customer, is covered separately. Bimp does not know the subcontractor’s price: the current amount is entered in the receipt from the certificate, and the plan in the specification is updated by hand when prices change. The expense item from the “Cost price” group is set in the service cards before the first document. Check button names in the interface against your version.
The difference between plan and actual was €250 on one batch of axles, and it became known on the day of the certificate. How to set up such accounting for your parts is described on the Bimp for manufacturers page.
FAQ
How do I show in the specification that a subcontractor performs an operation?
On the "Stages and operations" tab, choose a counterparty in the "Performer" column and specify the contract. A contract is mandatory for a subcontractor: then settlements for the work done are posted automatically when production is closed.
Where does the supplier order for the subcontractor come from?
It is created by the assembly. For outsourced operations you specify the supplier and the contract in the document, and after posting Bimp generates the supplier order.
How do I avoid overpaying a subcontractor?
Create the payment from the supplier order for which the service receipt was posted. The debt is then closed against the right document, and the "Supplier Settlements" report shows the closing balance for each contract.
Where does the delivery of parts from a subcontractor go?
Add it with the "Additional costs" document and the "Production" operation. The amount increases the batch cost and creates a debt to the carrier.
In a Bimp ERP demo a specialist enters one of your parts with subcontractor operations into the specification and shows the debt and the batch cost in the reports.
Book a demo